The last time I blogged was a good 2 months ago as the holiday season started hitting, so I certainly have some catching up to do. Even though I was out of the blogging game for a while I was still running a guerrilla campaign in the shadows reading lots of good articles on Pixlbit, Polygon, reading blogs, leaving comments occasionally, and listening to gaming podcasts. Over at Pixlbit, editor and writer Julian Titus put together quite a passionate Final Fantasy retrospective for the 25th anniversary which he worked on for several months. If you are of the Final Fantasy persuasion you should certainly check it out, but if you're not it's still a worthwhile adventure.
Since there's a bit to catch up on I'm going to break it into two blogs that should hopefully be easier to digest. This will be about the holidays, and the next blog will be all about the games I'm playing currently, post-holiday.
On Black Friday I was able to buy both Dishonored and Skyrim new for $25 a piece which was a great deal I couldn't pass up. I played through Dishonored and really loved what I found in the design. The story and characters didn't grab me much, and the final 3 levels of the game became pretty boring for me because everything I wanted to do in the game I was able to do plenty of in the previous 5 levels excluding the escape from prison tutorial, and it was amazing. Dishonored has some issues to improve upon whenever Harvey and the team begin work on the next game, but overall it's an amazing game that I can't recommend enough. I'm a fan of stealth action and my 3 favorite stealth games are now Splinter Cell Chaos Theory, Deus Ex HR, and Dishonored. I love the level design, there's always several paths to get to targets. Think about it like going from point A to E with points B, C, and D in between. And there are always at least two ways to deal with the assassinations. The non-lethal methods are the most fun to do and they are often quite creative and compelling. There were times in the game where I realized that being non-lethal doesn't automatically make you good and allow you to stand on moral high ground. I played the game non-lethal and I still made a lot of choices I wasn't proud of. I felt flawed, I felt human despite all these supernatural powers and weapons I had. Quite the achievement, Arkane.
Skyrim has been great. I'm playing on 360 and it's been solid, only 2 minor bugs in dozens and dozens of hours. If I could play on PC I'd prefer that because I'd like to have access to the mod community. It's the Nordic viking fantasy I always wanted and it's improved a great deal of the creative-direction problems Morrowind and especially Oblivion had. Morrowind was all about being huge, but the quests themselves were way too MMO and text-box conversations didn't help. Oblivion and Skyrim have some of the same qualities, but they are striking better balances and learning to execute better. Oblivion reduced the amount of content but made the side quests and guilds richer. With the use of the Radiant Questing system, Skyrim has been able to provide a natural progression to the previous systems and kill all the birds with one stone. The story driven side quests and guild quests are quite rich and fun but for the people that want to keep on going, the radiant quests as well as the miscellaneous quests will set up random adventures for you that aren't driven by story but are opportunities to quest, level, loot, etc. Oh, and there's two main quests outside of all that involving the dragons and the civil war that finally work and are much more interesting than the awful one Oblivion had going on.
Oblivion's biggest problems were the worst kind of problems, not bugs but creative design. The leveling, the interface, the character creation, exploring Oblivion, and the weapon/armor system that made only Glass and Deadric armors useful as well as easy to come across. Skyrim's systems-design is finally hitting all the right notes. Creating a character isn't a pain in the ass anymore, most of the enemies don't level up with you, and you can just play the game how you want and the skills you use increase. The perks you choose when you level are great and can change the combat pretty dramatically. Sneaking and using the bow is a blast. Melee combat is much slower, weightier, and bloodier than Oblivion. My favorite addition is now you can now craft all of your own armor, weapons, jewellery and enchant them with magic, and upgrade them through smithing so that every type of armor can be useful and cool for much longer. Since the beginning of the game I've only ever used equipment that I forged myself, so it gives you a sense of ownership and self-reliance. Jesus the system in Oblivion blew, Skyrim is a breath of fresh air and some good ideas finally.
I feel like a Nordic warrior living off the land, independent of the Empire, forging all my own goods, putting my sword through any Elf that tells me I can't worship Talos, and sneaking around the gorgeous aspen tree forests, tundra, and hot spring geysers hunting Elk as I hear a distant dragon's roar echo across the landscape while she flies miles away in the snowy mountain tops razing a Legion camp all before the sun sets and the aurora become visible. I love emergent gameplay and Skyrim is pretty great at making systems that can interact with one another in unscripted and fascinating ways making your experience feel sophisticated and polished yet completely chaotic and random.
So I bought myself Dishonored and Skyrim and I've enjoyed them both, but for Christmas my Dad bought me Halo 4. I've been a huge Halo universe fan since the beginning and some of the guys at Bungie are what made me interested in being a level designer. I love Halo campaigns, the Halo sandbox, co-op, Firefight, I've read 5 of the novels so far, I love the anime, I love making things in Forge. Halo 4 was a really fun game, but there's a lot to work on. Halo looks better than ever, it feels better than ever, it sounds better than ever. The guns literally roar, crack, and thunder in ways that make the previous games sound like muddy water by comparison. 343 is doing so many things right with Halo, but if I want to get into Halo talk it'll get down to why the level designers made a particular encounter space in a certain level a snowflake-ish shape and why it was confusing and had really bad flow of movement. When you come across the cartographer room there's some raised side edges on ramps when there shouldn't be because it requires me to either jump over or only run up from the front, disrupting flow.
There's unnecessary floor gaps in the Foreunner gondola architecture that led to some confusion and cheap deaths while I was in combat. Some of the level design is really great and provides a great Halo sandbox, but some other areas of the game feel awkward. I know for a fact this game was playtested to high heaven so I wonder how many others had the complaints I do, or maybe it's just me. I can understand the creative logic of why there's no huge Forge World map but several small ones instead (more variety), but I still don't like it. It's very difficult to absorb narrative in the campaign in many sequences because things are very chaotic and Cortana is yelling. Compounding the narrative absorption problem is the fact that she uses long-winded hard-science fiction terminology in the heat of battle to direct you when all you have to do is kill some Covies and go press a button at the end. When the pace is fast and combat is occurring you should keep it simple and "dumb" for lack of a better term. But when the pace slows down that's the right time to turn into Star Fleet Technical Manual. The Halo universe is dense and smart, and I understand the logic of why it's good to make a smart game with smart objectives giving purpose to the action, but the specific way it was done made it hard to absorb the majority of the time. Therefore for most of the campaign I had little idea what the hell was happening. It was gorgeous and action packed, but I didn't know what was happening until I consulted the wiki to get a clear idea. Oh, and there's no Firefight, that's bullshit. Huge shit right out of a bull. Halo 4 is really good and when I beat it I went straight back for a 2nd playthrough, but there's a lot of buts.
So those are the games I played back over holidays. In the next blog I'll do a gaming update showing you the games I've been playing currently, and I'll even tell you what my most anticipated game of 2013 is. Before I go I'll leave some amazing music that I've been listening to a lot.
Comments
Travis Hawks
Senior Editor
01/24/2013 at 11:12 PM
On your Halo 4 woes:
I guess they thought that Spartan Ops was a good replacement for Firefight, and it's sort of similar. I like it well enough, but I was not a big Firefight aficionado.
I never had the issues you had with the level layouts personally, but I know I got stuck in some stupid spots in earlier games and I am guessing I just got lucky this time around.
I agree with you about the way the story is told and how that needs to be fixed. That has been an issue since the first game for me, and it's a shame. For whatever reason, I too have been reading the Halo novels and they make me extra sad that the games don't reveal the Halo universe as elegantly as the books do. There is a ton of crossover between Halo 4, Spartan Ops, and the current books being released by Karen Traviss. If I hadn't read those books I know I would be even more confused than I already am by the in-game story.
On Dishonored:
It seems like many people have similar sentiments to you about the game's world and kind of losing interest towards the end. I definitely didn't have this problem. I had to force myself to turn the game off and get at least four hours of sleep before work every night that I played. Everything about that world really grabbed me, from the aesthetics, to the Outsider mythos, to the little still-life vignettes tucked in every out of the way room I could find. Ah well, I guess it just hit some sweet spot for me and didn't for others. I'm hoping that time will be kind to the game and people will look back at it and start appreciating it even more.
Michael117
01/25/2013 at 12:09 PM
There's still a chance that Spartan Ops will grow on me. I certainly don't hate it, but if it comes down to a choice I'd have to go with Firefight. Halo 4 is already packed with lots of good content, game modes, etc, so they definitely didn't send out an incomplete package by any stretch. I just really loved Firefight in ODST, and then the version in Reach was the best. I love it because you can play co-op or single player and it's always fun. Plus it's open ended if you want it to be and you can customize the experience, waves, weapons, and every other detail. And it basically gives you all the opportunities to play with the Halo sandbox and all the tools and just have Halo fun outside the campaign and multiplayer. I bet they will end up having it again at some point, maybe Halo 5 will bring it back. I can only hope.
I'm actually glad to hear that Dishonored grabbed you so much and engrossed you so much. The things that most intrigue me about the universe is the whales and the fallen continent of Pandyssia they talk about in the books you find around the game. I think it's cool that whales play such a huge role in the civilizations and that there's some kind of magical edge to them some mystery that I don't grasp or understand yet. I actually just started a second playthrough of the game this week and I came across this book about the Leviathan(s) which are some magical sea beasts maybe. It makes me wonder what's really going on under the oceans in their universe. What are the whales really like, what kind of intelligence do they have, what's the history behind the whales? How did it come to be that the whole civilization depends on their oil and there's so much whaling going on? What does Pandyssia look like, what happened to it? There's some interesting things going on in the Dishonored universe I want to know more about in the sequel.
Since I started the 2nd playthrough I've been having more fun this time around and upgrading the skills I know I love. Some of the story and characters were hit and miss for me, but I'm still in love with the gameplay and there's some mystery and wonder in the universe. I will get very excited for future games.
Travis Hawks
Senior Editor
01/25/2013 at 12:52 PM
Yes, the potential for Dishonored sequel stories is exciting. I hope they flesh it out even more and don't just move to a different universe using the same mechanics.
Log in to your PixlBit account in the bar above or join the site to leave a comment.
Comments