Forgot password?  |  Register  |    
User Name:     Password:    
Blog - User Feature   

Gaming's Movie Equivalents


On 07/22/2013 at 07:01 PM by Casey Curran

See More From This User »

I remember my friend here whatsacow has put a few blogs on what if video games were movies. I enjoyed these, but felt there were a few games that were missing, namely because there are a few games he hasn't played and there are some not everyone realizes. I'm not going for the obvious ones either because we all know Uncharted is Indiana Jones, Dead Space is Alien, and Batman is....Batman. Here's some ones we don't really think about though.

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2 --> Prometheus

This one you have to think about a little more. Both take a series which has not once been about answering any big questions. They were just sci-fi stories that entertained the viewer and if they ever said anything. Yet then this game comes and they're bringing out serious questions. Kotor 2 talks about the consequences of every small action and how everything's connected together while Prometheus answers the biggest one of all: Where did we come from?

Yet these were both criticized for their serious flaws and not seen as good as their predecessor. Then they just stumble at the end. Kotor 2 because it was rushed and Prometheus because....I still can't decide whether it's because the writers are hacks or it's them saying that question will never be answered.

Persona 4 --> The Breakfast Club

At its core, I think of Persona 4 like a good John Hughes movie. It's about teenagers coming to terms with their own personal problems and accepting who they are. Where their similarities really shine is how perfectly each captures what being a teenager is like. Their problems are relatable and many even remember being in these same situations. The only difference is that they're battling demons inside a strange world they access through a television instead of just being in detention together.

Heavy Rain --> Avatar

This is the strangest one of my picks, but just think about it and you'll realize why it's on here. Both claim to be some bold new innovation for the medium, but when you stop and think about it, you realize no one in their right mind would want gaming/films to turn into this. It's a nice distraction, but nothing revolutionary or that we need to take notes on. And despite these innovations, it has serious flaws in both characters and plot structure. Not something bad, just....don't turn the medium into this.

Not to mention both of their creators have annoyingly big egos.

Eternal Darkness --> The Sixth Sense

It's not that these are both horror games. Rather, it's the legacy they created. Both are fantastic pieces of entertainment that are brilliant in different ways. Then their creators went onto make something flawed, but still good. Then something pretty bad. Then something absolutely horrible. Now we just want them to go away.


 

Comments

Blake Turner Staff Writer

07/22/2013 at 08:22 PM

The eternal Darkness one is so true! Except that both follow up games were terrible...

Casey Curran Staff Writer

07/22/2013 at 08:28 PM

MGS: The Twin Snakes was actually the good one. Too Human is the bad one. Then X-Men Destiny is the terrible one

Blake Turner Staff Writer

07/22/2013 at 08:41 PM

Oh ok. They also made Legacy of Kain! Man, that series should be rebooted!

BrokenH

07/22/2013 at 08:27 PM

Funny, at some point I mentioned a Persona game with lovable "detention time outcasts" akin to "The Breakfast Club" would be the perfect game for me.

As great as Persona 4 was, I felt like the main protagonist Yu was too perfect and would have related to him more if he wasn't great at everything. (As well as him having EVERY FEMALE CHARACTER wanting to ride his joy-stick.)

I know that's just "Japan being Japan" when it comes to its' MCs but I can "dream" can't I? Maybe in Persona 5 the main protagonist will be more like Yosuke or Kanji. Tongue Out

Casey Curran Staff Writer

07/22/2013 at 08:31 PM

I didn't mind how perfect Yu is. He's not that much of a character even, he's more of a story element to better flesh out every other character. Really only one notch above a silent protagonist. Besides, he's hardly perfect. In fact, you can make him a really big asshole if you want. The point is though, he's comfortable with who he is.

BrokenH

07/22/2013 at 08:33 PM

Watch the Persona 4 anime,bro. Wink What I'm discussing here will become more clear.

Casey Curran Staff Writer

07/22/2013 at 09:50 PM

I did watch it. But I'm talking about the game.

BrokenH

07/22/2013 at 10:48 PM

To me the anime was a pretty good replica of the game too. (At least story wise) I even liked how the anime gave Yu a voice & a personality even though I still relate to Yosuke more.

Casey Curran Staff Writer

07/22/2013 at 11:08 PM

Still doesn't change that Yu is meant to be just a small step above Link/Ness/Pokemon Trainer in the game iteslf in terms of character. The anime wasn't made until the game was popular enough to justify it after all.

BrokenH

07/22/2013 at 11:26 PM

That's true! I wasn't trying to nitpick,btw. lol. I do think Yu was a step up from the previous blue haied orphan protagonist in P3 though. Aka, he had a family he interacted with and even had a fetish for pulling off magic tricks. It's not much of a leap up from "Link" or "Ness" but it is noticeable.

Super Step Contributing Writer

07/23/2013 at 12:53 AM

I more or less agree with the last two. Since I hadn't played the follow-up Silicon Knights games, I thought it was going to be how both Sixth Sense and ED relied more on mindfucks than jump scares, but I see what you did.

I got to watch Avatar on the jumbotron in Cowboys stadium a summer or two ago. It held up as a popcorn flick, but I never thought making a world with blue elves that look like they came from a PC World Magazine cover was "revolutionary." And I keep being told I'm misremembering, which given that I merely watched a Let's Play of it once, is very possible, but I'm pretty sure my issue with Heavy Rain [spoilers?] was that the detective went to the bathroom in that clock shop, and wasn't the woman still there to witness whatever the hell? So how did ... eh, fuck it, it's literally been years since I watched that Let's Play, and I don't feel like watching it again. 

Chris Yarger Community Manager

07/23/2013 at 06:41 AM

You say that Uncharted is like Indiana Jones, but as I played I felt as if it were more along the lines of National Treasure with more guns and less Nicholas Cage (Thank God). Of course, my only experience so far has been with the first Uncharted game, I have the rest of trilogy on standby though!!

NSonic79

07/25/2013 at 08:44 PM

You just sold me on Persona 4.

Log in to your PixlBit account in the bar above or join the site to leave a comment.