PixlBit

I'm not much into horror games, so I say Tales of Xillia 2. I say use the money on the collector's edition but it's a bit more than $75.

Given your tastes in games, I say #3 is the best bet for you. Otherwise, I've heard from fans and reviews alike that Alien and Evil Within have upsides that are also downsides. Space between save points adds tension in Alien, but is also frustrating and Evil Within uses older horror game mechanics and I remember reading it's also presented in a letterbox format, so mileage may vary. I'm getting these opinions second-hand though, so take my input with grains of salt. Maybe throw some butter in there since it's Christmas.

Knowing you, go with Xillia 2. I agree with what Super Step Said about Alien and Evil Within. Evil Within was my game of the year, but it is very old school in it's gameplay mechanics, and if you didn't enjoy Resident Evil 4 and later games, you won't like it either-- actually I can see non-fans getting frustrated. As much as I loved the atmosphere of Alien, I got very annoyed with the lack of checkpoints. Hope this helps? 

awesome man!  I dunno, like the others said, Xillia is probably more of your style, though I heard it's not as good as the first one.  

good choice on physical. Though low priced those digital sales were weak sauce compared to the beginning of the year.