Posted on 11/11/2014 at 11:16 AM
| Filed Under Blogs
At this point, I've long since given up on professional reviewers, but I didn't really care much about them to begin with. I started losing interest in gaming magazines when they moved away from talking about how to beat games I liked and started focusing more heavily on reviews and other shit like that.
Most of the games I enjoy are 7s and 8s in the world of game reviewing. A few are 9s. Most of the 9.5s and 10s, with the exception of Zelda games, are games that put me to sleep. Of the hundreds of games I own, I can count the games I own made by EA, Activision, or Ubisoft on the fingers of one hand..
My one quibble with game review scores that's hard to ignore is Metacritic. Its weighting is skewed. Because of our years in school, Americans are used to seeing 70-79 as a "C", or mediocre, and anything below 70 as a failing grade. Metacritic does even worse: if a game site uses a school-style letter grading system, Metacritic weighs a "C" as a 50, which is a grade a student that is either mentally slow or simply completely fucked off in class gets. Sadly, Metacritic does impact the games somewhat. Fallout: New Vegas was a better game in most ways than Fallout 3. Obsidian simply did a far better job on the franchise than Bethesda Game Studios did The 84 aggregate it got on Metacritic kept Obsidian from profiting on it (the game sold very well, but Obsidian lost a bonus they really needed from Bethesda specifically because of the score) and it all but ensures that Obsidian will never work on the series again. And that's just one example. I'm pretty sure that some developers see the hostile reception their games get on MC and it kills their enthusiasm for making games that follow-up to some perfectly decent and fun products.
But I agree with the main point of your story. It's ridiculous getting so over-the-top angry over game reviews. My flip response has always been that getting angry at game journalism is like getting violently angry at Cupcake Baking Monthly or Model Airplane Enthusiast. But really, game reviews are irrelevant. What I wouldn't give for a Nintendo Power-style gaming publication that sticks with how to find every secret in good games instead of gushing over the latest annual EActubi refreshes!