Posted on 04/13/2012 at 11:50 AM
| Filed Under Review
I've tried countless times to get into the Silent Hill games and I just can't do it. I've played Origins (which was crap), 4 (which was even crappier), 1 (which was just vague), and 2... which I just can't connect with. I can appreciate the subtleties of the narrative and I think that subtext is extremely interesting, but the actual game part of it just isn't very good and that's been true of all of the games in the series I've played.
Controls are clunky, objectives and puzzles are obtuse, and quite frankly, I've never felt it to be scary. What I find most odd is that people continue to defend SH2 despite how dated it is by today's standards. Resident Evil doesn't seem to get a pass on this, and maybe that's because they've made strides with later games to improve them on a functional basis, but I find it odd that SH is exempt from this criticism.
That being said, I think this is a great review that properly highlights for fans what they can expect from the HD remakes. From your perspective Julian, do you think the games hold up fairly well, or is the driving force of your adoration more nostalgia?
Follow on question - do you think they'd be well-served to flat-out remake these games with more functional controls, new graphics, and better direction? I know I want them to because I really want play these games, but I just get hung up on the problems too quickly and abandon them after a few short hours.