Thanks for you warm welcome, Nick. I'll stick around for sure, especially when searching for reviews. :)
I played and watched the game played in Italian, and that voice acting is really bad, but I don't know about the English one.
Anyway, I wonder if the good reviews are all honest ones, or if there is something behind it... you know what I mean. ;)
I heard of pressures on reviewers for a different Ubi game, after all, so I don't completely trust famous sites or magazines.
Anyway, in a scale of 10 I would give RS2 a 7: a game that works, but with a gameplay I don't like and other problems (and quite short, too).
For example, I didn't like much the controls, either, since the camera is linked to the sword movements and that can get confusing unless you always use lock-on.
Also, I didn't like that the gameplay is combo-based, I would have preferred a more intuitive and natural swordplay style, since mixing buttons and pre-definite gestures kills a bit the whole "motion control" appeal for me: instead, I loved Wii Spoerts Resort... it just feel more natural and accessible, but still deep in its way.
Finally, I didn't like how they mixed motion control actions with buttons-controlled ones: it's incoherent.
For example, of the 3-4 different type of doors in the game, only one you can open with a gesture, while for all the other ones you've to press the A button... and there are other things like this that disrupt the flow of the game and someway confuse the player, at least in my opinion.