I'd be very interested to see that full list of games and maybe some reviews of them, perhaps in the context of what they each say about the era they came from. I'd read that blog if you wrote it, for sure. I wonder if I'd feel the same way about Toy Story for SNES as you might about Toy Story 2. I definitely remember playing the SNES game a lot, but I also remember that RC Car level being the devil of alternate control hell. I share your disinterest for CoD, though; to the point I'm not sure I can enjoy it even on the "dumb fun" level that you claim to enjoy it on. Maybe that comes from boring, music-less multiplayer matches, though. I have a feeling I'd like these games more if I experienced the single player campaigns.
I actually pride myself with keeping up with movies, and last year I may as well have been a professional critic. But, aside from seeing Catching Fire today, I barely caught much of anything released this year. I'm not upset about it, though, aside from missing out on seeing Gravity in theaters. I have money in my pocket that I didn't spend going to movies with friends while I was still taking Graduate classes, and plenty of time over this winter break for my family to take me to the Hobbit, Wolf of Wall Street, American Hustle, or whatever else I may want to see.
I have been awful with keeping up with video games the past few years though, because I simply can't justify the expense of them. Luckily, now I have a good laptop, so Steam and its sales should help me play more than just online Tetris and other free, streaming retro games. Hopefully, I can find at least a few gems, as you have these past few years.
Six actually sounds like a high number to me as far as games finished in a year. I've certainly rented more than that some years, but I tend to only finish short rentals or games I own, and I don't own too many games to begin with.
I know what you mean about playing review scores against your own interests. I asked for Golden Sun one year for Christmas on the basis of its amazing review scores, completely ignoring that I really dislike turn-based combat JRPGs for the most part. I figured "well, I liked Paper Mario, Super Mario RPG and Pokemon at least ok, and this looks real pretty and has great reviews, so it must be so amazing that even I'll love it."
I actually used to have way more fun with games EGM gave 7.0s or similar to, like Sly Cooper, etc., and at one point started regarding games they gave 7.0s to higher than those they gave 8.0s when making my rental decisions. I think they might have docked points for something not having enough replay value or being meaty enough, but since I was just renting for the mostpart, that didn't bother me.
I've since learned to see reviews as the subjective texts they really are, and pay more attention to why a certain Metacritic or Rottentomatoes score is given than what that score is, if I'm interested in whatever is being reviewed. For the most part, anyway. There are definitely instances where I say to myself, "I'll go see or play this only if it gets a high rating." I'm usually right to do that though, so it works for me, I guess.