Astynanax was one of the worst NES games I remember playing as a kid. I rented it and wanted my money back. I remember putting in a cheat code just so I could beat it and say I got my money's worth.
I have similar feelings about gaming growing up. I had friends that played games, but few of them were as passionate about it as I was, at least until high school. I was the leader of the nerds back then (oh, I guess I am now, too) and I remember in the months leading up to the N64 me and my friend Devon would always pass each other in the hallways and say "Mario 64 rules!". I had a lot of friends that were casual gamers, which was why I started writing PlayStation Revolution. Sidenote: I tried selling PSR at Gamefellas before I started working there. They didn't put it on the news stand, but I think it's one of the things that led to me getting a job there.