I debated scoring this 4.5, but ultimately I think 4 is a more apt score. It doesn't really take the series to new places (though I am glad to see it back), and its replayability hinges entirely on a player's tolerance for perfecting their scores in missions. For me, Pilotwings is all about that, but I realize that most are going to blaze through the missions and quit when they're done.
That being said, if you're a Pilotwings fan, you could consider the score as half a point higher. The presentation is the real killer here, as is the play-it-safe gameplay that doesn't move the series along in any meaningful way.


