Posted on 02/01/2018 at 12:07 AM
| Filed Under Feature
Yeah, since there was such along time between episodes I only put the call out on twitter.
Thoughts about the Giant Bomb deliberations. I have a lot of them.
I thought the world building debate was absurd, and I was genuinely shocked that they couldn't come to a consensus on what world building is, and equally shocked that, not only did Horizon not win the category, it wasn't even in the top 3. That game is like 80% world building, and is the main reason I love it so much.
No animosity between Alex and anyone else. Alex has his battles and will fight for them. Now, if Fire Pro was disqualified for not having been released at the time of recording, I think it's total bullshit that PUBG wasn't disqualified. They took it as fact that the game would actually release in 2017, and I think they all gave it a pass because they had pretty much already decided it was GOTY way before sitting down to record.
I was curious how Ben and Abby would mesh in that room. I like Abby a ton on the Beastcast, but lowkey can't stand anything Ben says or does. I felt like Ben never added anything of merit to any of the discussions. I was surprised at how ready to mix things up Abby was, but the longer the discussion went on, the more I decided that she must not be much of a reader. She seems to pull from the same limited vocabulary. Maybe I do that too, but at some point I was trying to see if I could count all the times she said "very" "cool", and "good".
But my main take away was that this was the first time in a decade that I have not only disagreed with the GB top 10, but it actively made me angry. You can probably tell from my top 5 list that I wasn't pleased with their list, and as someone who really doesn't understand why people love Nier, I was shocked when JEFF GERSTMANN of all people tried to get it in as the top game.