Excellent editorial J-Bone. I'm on the fence about this game and for now I'm going to sit back and see how it releases, and what people think of it. Hopefully you guys get the chance to review it and get your thoughts out.
Back when we started talking about Tomb Raider and how unsettling it was that they said they "needed" an M rating to tell a mature story, I had doubts about the game. As time goes on everytime I see something cool about the game, there's always something offputting to balance it out. Back when they showed that trailer where Croft was evading enemies and environmental dangers on that boat, I thought that was cool, that felt like some interesting survival gameplay. I'd like to see more evasion, stealth, and exploration in my adventure games.
But then it gets balanced out by the devs making statements about me needing to protect her. I don't want to take care of her and coddle her, I want to be her and embrace her character as my own avatar in this world of survival.
Other things that balanced out my excitement and made me "meh" on this game is that when I saw the E3 gameplay from last week it just looked like every game I've ever played. It looked like Uncharted with boobs, Splinter Cell, Last of Us, Assassin's Creed, everything just put together with a "different" skin. During one of the podcasts Esteban said that, "People who say that Tomb Raider is just Uncharted, need to remember that Uncharted is just Tomb Raider." I don't buy into that at all. The Tomb Raider series fell out of favor with people I would assume, otherwise why would they be rebooting it like this? The Uncharted series came out and basically became everything TR should've been in the first place, and now TR is trying to play "catch up" with the younger whipper snapper series that it influenced.
This game just looks like everything I've played before, but with tits and a pretty face. I've seen characters suffer before, I've seen blood in games, broken limbs, crying, etc. I've seen characters go through trilas of fire, I don't see why it's going to matter in TR. They have a lot to prove, and I'm on the fence about it so I'm not going to be playing. I hope they change my mind.