Yeah the whole World debate was crazy. I thought these things were more or less hammered out before a podcast records. At least to where a main host, Gerstman, can reiterate it's meaning to the rest of the cast when they ask. It was definitely entertaining to hear the actual debate but it should never have come to that. I honestly can't recall the Top 3, just that Zelda won and Horizon wasn't in it. I completely agree with you. Horizon was amazing in that subject. I was so enthralled into that universe. I wanted every piece of info I could find. The locations were interesting and the robosaurs peppered throughout the land was unlike any other game I've played. Should have been top 3 easy but I agree it should have won.
I didn't even think about that PUBG comment. It could easily have been pushed back a few weeks. They were lucky it wasn't. Think it'll be done differently this year. That said, I'm loving PUBG on Xbox despite its flaws. I can agree 100% with what they said about the tense battles. I don't see it being GOTY but it deserves a spot on the top 10 in my opinion.
I'm still debating on Ben. I like him a bit more than I did initally but I could easily go without him. Abby has been fine on Beastcast (outside that Australian sister bit...) but I was getting tired of the Cuphead comment after the 5th time and I'm sure it was about double that. Also Dream Daddy wouldn't have made it without her so she loses a point or 3 lol.
The top 10 also surprised me. PUBG was almost no where else in the awards so seeing it go 1 was strange. I fully anticipated Zelda winning or maybe Mario. Gerstman also caught me off guard with how hard he was fighting for Nier. He stated how he was walking into that day thinking it would win #1 and I was shocked. I am definitely a fan of Nier: Automata but I couldn't back it as #1. It just didn't seem like a game he would be championing.
Cuphead was great but I feel it was too high. Let's be real here, that game with any other generic skin over it is not even being mentioned here. Game play was perfectly fine but not ground breaking. The art is a HUGE factor and that's fine but shouldn't push it to a GOTY contender in my opinion.
Destiny 2 was a blast for the month or 2 I played it but like most I dropped it hard and can't see myself diving back in. I can't really comment on the last 4 but I'm so disappointed that Horizon got no love on this list. Especially when I see Dream Daddy on it. Horizon got snubbed because of its close proximity to Zelda. There's no other way I can fathom it being so unloved by the majority. I'm not saying everyone should be in love with it but it deserved more than what it got.