I was blogging heavily when DNF came out, and that's around the time that I started a series called Reviews After the Hype. When games come out and have a lot of hype or expectation surrounding them it always feels like they're either the best game ever made or an atrocity and offensive to everyone. The truth is usually in the middle. Duke Nukem Forever isn't a good game by any stretch, but it's also not the travesty that people accuse it of being. It's a decidedly low-tier shooter that would have been mind blowing had it come out 4 years earlier.
Good luck on those underwater levels towards the end, though.