Super Mario Bros. 3 will never be toppled in my eyes. Maybe if World actually did something with its world map, like what 3 did by turning the map into a game itself, it would challenge 3. Both are perfect vidoe games, but 3 is just a little bit perfecter.
I loathe 3D platformers, so none of those would make the list, except maybe 3D World since there is a bit more (but not much more) precision required.