While this reply has been a long time coming, I just thought I share my two-cents on this review as a whole. I pretty much agree with everything that Nick said; its a fantastic game, and Nick reviewed it fairly unlike MOST gaming media outlets (Gamespot). Skyward Sword wants you, the player, to interact with it, and this made it easily my GoTY (tied with Mario 3D Land, Pushmo and Portal 2).
But I am just going to say this; if you write this game off as a waggle fest or a bad game because of it's controls, you are obviously doing something wrong. OH WELL.