Arkham Asylum is still the best imo, followed by City. They got the balance right.
Please tell me you're just using a screenshot from the web and you are playing the 2D sprite version of Rondo of Blood and not that ugly 2.5 version. I absolutely loathe when 2D games get remade with 3D models (see: Bomberman, Flashback, Bionic Commando: Rearmed). Here's an opinion piece (not mine) that partly explains why:
http://insomnia.ac/commentary/of_genocides_and_reinventions/