Posted on 06/21/2015 at 03:33 PM
| Filed Under Blogs
I'm surprised EA and Ubisoft haven't tried this before, honestly. There was talk of big companies financing games like Shenmue III and BGE 2 from the instant the "Double Fine Adventure"'s Kickstarter was announced, and I don't doubt for a bit that there has been discussion in the boardrooms of EA, Ubisoft, Activision, Nintendo, Sony, or Microsoft about the possibility of risk mitigation through Kickstarter for big games.
As it is, though, a lot of the enthusiasm for Kickstarter in the gaming community has cooled. Double Fine's final product - the very game that ignited the crowdfunding craze in gaming - was less than what enthusiastic gamers were expecting, and that was after numerous delays. Leisure Suit Larry: Reloaded turned out to be a one-off deal. Star Citizen has secured hundreds of millions in crowdfunding but doesn't seem to have any release window. A lot of Kickstarter games have failed outright. At least Shenmue III has a better chance than most KS projects of seeing the light of day as a finished product. Sony has hopefully enough of a hand in its development that they can set milestones and impose accountability on Ys Net that they will actually get the game done. Broken Age was so troubled because Double Fine had no accountability to anyone, including the people that paid into their Kickstarter.
The simple fact remains, nobody was willing to finance Shenmue III without some mitigation of the risk. Shenmue II was a failure on Xbox, while Shenmue I has a reputation, somewhat undeserved, for having damaged Sega financially. That myth has been largely debunked but still persists in peoples' minds. People can cheer all they want at E3, but crowd noise doesn't equal sales, because E3 isn't really representative of the gaming market, it's just a big spectacle. I'd love to have a HD remaster but despite what you or I think, everybody with money refused to take the risk of even that, so here we are. Short of Yu Suzuki winning the jackpot at the Powerball or a state lottery in the United States, the game simply wasn't going to happen.