I felt Adam Sessler was very fair as well. He honestly expressed his opinion about something that made him feel uncomfortable about the game, without assuming that the developers or GOW fans were horrible people. Mackey's problem is that he attacks people and makes harmful assumptions and generalizations. Sessler was even handed, fair, and criticized a very popular franchise. Mackey was the opposite and jumped on a niche title with a small fan base. While Mackey was trolling for page views, he did it in a very mean and cowardly way. It still bothers me when I remember it. I didn't even like the game (Hyperdimension Neptunia), but his comments about it were way off... Ugh... I'm letting him troll me again... lol.
The thing is, I get why some people are going to have problems with some aspects of certain games. I get the whole "Sorceress" thing in Dragon's Crown, and I get the "gigolo glasses" thing in Killer is Dead. I don't get thinking that Suda 51 and George Kamitani are horrible people though. They made an artistic choice. It's their personal vision. Anyone has the right to not like it, and to not buy the game. It should really be as simple as that... You don't like it? That's cool. You want to tell me why you don't like it? That's cool too. You want to tell me I'm a bad person for buying or playing the game? Not cool.